Better to Burn Out Than to Fade Away?

This story may not be true because I got it from Al.

Not “Artificial Intelligence.” I mean my brother Al, who is likewise prone to fact-free hallucinations.

Either way, I think it’s instructive.

The story involves a New York attorney who came up with a gradual retirement plan for himself.

Here’s how it worked…

Each weekday, for decades, the man left his house in the suburbs and took the same morning train to his office in Manhattan. At the end of each day, he took the same evening train home.

His plan was that as he approached retirement, with each passing year, he would take the next, later train to work in the morning. Then, at the end of each day, he would go home one train earlier.

The overall effect would be a progressive shortening of his workday.

Eventually, the year would arrive when his two train schedules got so close together that his day would consist of taking the train inbound, walking across the station platform, and immediately taking the next train home.

At that point, he would be fully retired.

Now I don’t know about you, but true or not, I can’t help but admire the elegant simplicity behind this gradual approach – the polar opposite of stopping on a dime.

This is a man who has given a lot of thought to how he wants his career to end.

Different Strokes for Different Folks

According to a survey by Principal Financial Group (see, I occasionally do research), about half of workers prefer this kind of “phased approach.” The other half could not be reached because they are all out playing golf 24/7.

No, that’s not true. The other half want to retire the more traditional way – working full time until they stop all at once on a given day.

Of course, not everyone works for themselves or has the option to stop work gradually, whether due to company policy or the nature of the work itself.

But many people do. That might include things like reduced work hours, job sharing, altered responsibilities, consulting back to the company, or hiding in the bathroom for part of each day.

When my dad retired after 40 years with the same company (in the same building!), he negotiated a year’s worth of free office space. Every day, he got up, put on a suit and tie, and took the train to “work.”

I’m not sure what he did once he got to his office. But by holding on to some of the previous aspects of work, it made his eventual transition to full retirement easier.

A Change is Gonna Come

As I contemplate my own future retirement, stopping abruptly feels to me like a much harder transition than does slowly fading away. Like hair loss, I’d prefer my career didn’t vanish overnight.

Plus, as William Bridges points out in his book, Transitions, the change in work circumstances may not be the hardest part:

“Change is situational. Transition, on the other hand, is psychological. It is not the events but rather the inner reorientation and self-redefinition that you have to go through in order to incorporate any of those changes into your life.”

In other words, whether your move from full-time work to complete retirement occurs over the course of one day, one month, one year, or longer, there’s still an adjustment that needs to be managed.

That’s why when (if) my retirement time comes, I intend to turn the volume down slowly, giving myself a chance to transition to a different life:

What’s difficult? What’s missing? What’s new? What impact will the change in my life have on the other people already in it?

For me, figuring that out is something I want to do over a period of years, not hours.

Maybe I should start taking the train to work.


Comments

16 responses to “Better to Burn Out Than to Fade Away?”

  1. I think for me the decision fell into place when I retired TO something (a hobby I developed over 3 years that became a post-work “career”), not just AWAY from something (my 45-year moneymaking career). If you love what you do, there’s no legal requirement to retire. But for others, I can imagine having to abruptly retire before you choose to retire would be rough. (“Transitions” is a great book, btw).

    1. That sounds like a nice transition, Jeannie!

  2. William Bridges’s book ‘Transitions’ is a really helpful read regarding retirement as well as other major life stages.

    Personally, I had planned a gradual phasing out of full-time working but was not given that option and retired from full-time work abruptly. And, it has certainly taken time to build a new self-image and become fully engaged in a new phase of my life. Loving it now, but it has been difficult and painful (sometimes) getting here.

    1. I’m glad you have settled in. I agree that the self-image part is significant!

  3. For most of my career as an independent consultant, certainly the past few years, I have not been working for paying clients at capacity. Accordingly, I have dedicated more time to marketing my Public Relations and Marketing Communications services.

    The fact that I am still not working at capacity tells you something about the success of that activity.

    Meanwhile, I was available to escort my mother to medical appointments and pitch in when my grandchildren needed supervision.

    I’ve been in an easing down mode and expect to continue to ease down; I will stop taking new clients and hold onto the last paying client until they pull the plug.

    Starting this summer, when my husband retires from his full-time, on premises job, we will be swimming, hiking and playing tennis almost daily, instead of on the weekends. In the cooler months, I will look on websites as a volunteer for nonprofits seeking writing and editorial assistance.

    Plus, I plan to start a monthly folk dancing group in the community.

    1. A full plate, for sure!

  4. My self-image has never been tied to what I get paid to do, so I’m not too concerned about the transition in that respect. Only my financial security. My government-suggested “full retirement” date is 15 months away. My plan is to switch from a well-paid corporate job to an entrepreneurial venture. I have slowly begun building that business so that, at my retirement date, I can jump from current job to one where I can have some measure of control over the hours I spend working. My goal is to eventually outsource some of the tasks, and checking in periodically to ensure it’s running smoothly. But I’m also aware that the best laid plans…. you know how that goes!

    1. Yes, the plans can definitely change. But it sounds like you’ve done a nice job of thinking things through. Wishing you all the best in your next adventure, Cindi!

  5. During lunch with one of my sons recently, we had an illuminating conversation about our different career stages. He shared his excitement about finally hitting his “stride” after the frustrations of learning his new profession.

    When he asked about my semi-retirement, I mentioned the book “Transitions,” particularly the section on “Endings.” While he’s eager to contribute independently, I find myself at the opposite end of the spectrum—with enough experience to perform my job almost automatically, which has led to a certain monotony.

    This contrast highlighted something important to both of us: we’re both on a journey, just at different points in path. His involves mastering new skills, while mine involves embracing the conclusion of a well-traveled road and preparing for something new in full retirement.

  6. That’s a great story, Jim. We all think we want things to be “easy,” but too easy can become boring. And by the way, I believe it was you who turned me on to the Transitions book!

  7. Literacy Avatar
    Literacy

    Every 5 years I asked the strategic question is my career going where I want and would make adjustments ( 3 years ago we started talking about my retirement and the impact on cash flow as I was self employed with no pension. We gave up my vehicle ( since I was working remotely for a company full time) to see if we could manage. I agree with starting to find new things that give you purpose. I like mentoring so I sought out new opportunities that I could do in retirement. Transition went well because 5 years ago I asked what does retirement look like and started making a vision

    1. Advance planning seems to have made an important difference for you. Thanks for sharing that!

  8. I remember going to my father-in-law’s retirement party, where one of the gifts was a park bench. Which is consistent with the America Dream, and funny, but it just doesn’t sit well with me. I can’t see my way to happiness and fulfillment being still.

    1. Better than a watch, I suppose. It never made sense to me why that was the standard retirement gift at precisely the time you didn’t need to be anyplace on time anymore!

  9. Fade out is my preference. If at all. I might still be working till the end!

    I’m lucky to have been in business for 20+ years and can now pick and choose the work I want to do. I’m saying no more to certain jobs. What I’ve also done is create guidelines. For example, on Tuesday, I play with my grandkids. I commit to 6-8 weeks of vacation a year. Rarely do I work on weekends anymore—I focus more on community, friends, and giving.

    1. I like the sound of that!