Trial and Error

“How about a tour guide?”

I had been talking with my wife, Linda, over breakfast about possible things I could get involved in, as I work less and retire more.

Hmm… she might be on to something.

After all, I like public speaking, and having exhausted my supply of available children, this would expose me to a never-ending population of new people to whom I could tell the same jokes over and over again.

But where?

The Boston Freedom Trail?

Nah. I have no interest in donning a powdered wig, dressing up as Benjamin Franklin, and shouting  “Hear Ye!” a hundred times a day.

Museum of Fine Art?

Too quiet. Besides, the sandwiches in the restaurant cost like $40 each. I’d have to work full-time just to break even.

Fenway Park?

Now that just might work.

It’s a Boston landmark visited by people from all over the world. Plus, I’d probably get a bunch of free tickets to games, concerts, and other events.

So I jumped in my car – literally, that same morning – and drove the 25 miles into Boston for the 11 am tour, to see for myself what it was like.

This is the part where I’m supposed to tell you I am now an official Fenway Park Tour Guide.

Except… that’s not what happened.

Sure, it was kind of interesting. Lots of history, and there’s something fascinating about being in a huge venue like that when it’s empty.

But I quickly learned that the Fenway tour is much less about the story and layout of the building itself than it is about baseball.

And while I don’t hate the game, I’m a long way from caring that, “In the summer of 1948, Ted Williams ate five hot dogs in between innings before hitting a home run at his next at bat.”

Granted, I probably made that up.

But it’s more or less the kind of thing discussed during the tour, which helped me decide it, and tour-guiding more broadly, is probably not for me.

So, was my trip into Boston that morning a waste of time?

Not at all.

As Thomas Edison famously said after failing more than 10,000 times on his way to inventing the lightbulb, “I have not failed. I have simply realized I couldn’t care less what that Ted Williams fellow eats for lunch.”

Solutions Are Not Universal

In my role as a (fabulously well-regarded) marketing consultant, I have spent the past 25+ years encouraging people to narrow their focus:

Tell people you do one thing and one thing only.

People want to hire experts. You need to become the leading expert in something.

Getting hired is winner-take-all. The best way to get to the front of the line is to be the only one in it.

That kind of thing.

And the truth is, especially for small firms and independents who live in a word-of-mouth world, it works really, really well.

But that’s marketing. And marketing is not reality – it’s oversimplified, fictionalized truth.

You know, like your Tinder profile, minus the exaggeration about your height or the lie about how much you enjoy long walks on the beach.

The thing is, deciding what to do in this next phase of life – when suddenly, all the doors and options are wide open – is the exact opposite.

It’s not about simplicity, and it’s definitely not about certainty.

It’s about experimentation – trying lots of different things as a means of figuring out what you want to get involved in, whether that’s giving tours of Fenway Park or something(s) else entirely.

To me, it feels a little bit the way it did when I was 18, back when I had no idea where I was going to live, what I was going to do, or who I was going to spend the rest of my life with.

Scary? Definitely. But fun all the same.

Well, I’m trying to get that mindset back again: investigating things in a way that’s messy, uncertain, and sure to be filled with dead ends and wrong turns.

Let’s just hope it doesn’t require 10,000 attempts.


Discussion Questions

  1. After how many tries at inventing the lightbulb would you have given up and moved on to something else? (My number is six.)
  2. Have you ever eaten five hot dogs in one sitting?
  3. What have you tried in terms of a retirement-related activity that was a complete miss?

Share your answers below…


Comments

13 responses to “Trial and Error”

  1. I looked on a website for opportunities to volunteer as a writer, working virtually from my home. I found an organization that supported women veterans of the armed services. The group’s officers were all volunteers and had worked together for a few years. They communicated by Slack, which was not something I monitored closely. By the time I would chime in, the matter had been resolved, but not in the optimal way I would have suggested. They were Amateurs, with an upper case letter A. I resigned.

    1. Sounds like you dodged a bullet on that one!

  2. I have tried to replicate my working activities as a volunteer. I have approached about a half dozen charities asking if they needed any help with data analysis or, if they conducted research, help conducting or fine-tuning that research. Mostly my inquiries were unanswered 🙁 One agency did reply, and that led to a successful but brief engagement.

    1. Ouch. Why do you think it worked in that one instance?

      1. Roland Stark Avatar
        Roland Stark

        It’s hard to say. Maybe because I had previously met the contact at that agency.

        1. That seems telling. Always more productive to approach people we already know, I guess.

  3. Ah yes, the famous or infamous word ‘retirement’. Sometimes it sounds like a new chapter, and at other times something to push to the back of the drawer for another day. I looked the word up in the dictionary and the first definition in the Cambridge, albeit the English German version was:

    The act of leaving your job and stopping working, usually because you are old.

    There was a little B2 in a circle by the sentence, so I really hope that was to define the level of English required to understand the word.
    It did however, bring a grin to my face as I thought ‘speak for yourself’.

    I’m still working well past the official retirement age. Yes, that may make me old(er) but doesn’t mean I’m decrepit and out to pasture.
    I have a forward thinking employer who works on the assumption that if you can do the job and have all your marbles, why not? Us ‘Oldies’ have a different work ethic than the young today. Decades ago (yes really, raised eyebrows, but if I’m honest it was still into middle age) we used to party until the wee hours, grab breakfast, change clothes and roll into work on a Saturday morning at the crack of sparrows. Most airports work 20 hours out of 24 if not 24/24.
    God forbid we should even think of calling in sick, especially at the weekend. Today, the phone call by the young to planning, is usually made in advance on a Friday afternoon … just in case the pumpkin changes at the wrong hour and the mice don’t get home in time.

    I have also dabbled with changing directions ever since I was young(er) and that ‘word’ was bandied around whilst some other colleagues kept popping the question. (No, not that question). I too, went for a spin as a part-time tour bus guide (thinking I was being proactive before the big R. of course) but a strange version of temporary ADHD overcame me, when I thought of saying the same thing over and over and over again, even if it was jollied up. With the scenery in Switzerland I’d be prone to forgetting the date some foreigner invaded and built a church, and be pointing out the different ways to visit various mountains and lakes. Explaining what they should be seeing rather than pay a fortune for a bog standard very expensive bus tour. (Hmm – that may just have given me another idea) Don’t fret though, everyone has invaded Switzerland at one time or another.

    I was also a high powered jet setting EA/OBM and VA at one time, and yes, I could do that again if I truly got my act together (just a slightly lower power setting now) but the travel part of my brain is saying ‘yes, that’s ok, but not full time. You still have the southern hemisphere and part of the South Pacific to see’. A definite non negotiable and certainly not postponable.
    If screeching past retirement age with a detour or two for a few small health issues has taught me anything, it is, DO NOT put anything off that has been sitting on your bucket list. Tomorrow is not a given. True, that can apply at any age but it hits closer to home at the top end of the scale.
    Which creates a dilemma (just a minor hiccup really). Balancing what I intend to do, (think positive here) with actual circumstances. What do I really want to do first? Or together? Or change? Even Chatgpt and Gemini can’t keep up with me sometimes.
    Gemini you have to work on airlines serving a destination , even if you do ask Google flights. I shouldn’t have to tell you.
    So this morning, it looks like a part time remote job, downsize the apartment, choose the date, book the ticket and off I go for a few months. Come back to my current job as a part timer, if the boss is still amenable.
    BUT tonight, may look completely different. I may have decided to live in Costa Rica, Spain, or Thailand, teach English online run guided tours for foreigners and answer emails and arrange travel remotely for someone on the other side of the world.

    What ever I do and however I do it, I’m damn sure it’ll be interesting and the planning, changing and rearranging is and will be more than half the fun. So stay curious, learn something new, and remember the word ‘retirement’ can also mean, mature adult, young in brain and spirit, having reams of experience ready to pass to the next generation. (There’s an idea for you Michael) Just don’t give up on yourself.

    1. Good perspective. Thank you.

  4. Why don’t you try keynote speaking or stand up comedy. Start with recording your Tedx talk. If the official org doesn’t give you a slot record and distribute it yourself anyway. All your subscribers will listen. Also don’t give up on tourguiding, you might just need to keep looking for the right niche, clearly not baseball fields. There is something interesting for the curious everywhere. At the very least the attempts will make good newsletter fodder. Don’t rule out a session or two with a transition coach. At the very least you will know whether you want their job or not…

    1. Great suggestions, Hayley! Especially the idea of future newsletter fodder. Thank you.

  5. Laura Kelly Avatar
    Laura Kelly

    I’m having lots of fun trying out various boondoggles in my early post-retirement phase. Not worrying about “but what does it pay?” has opened up many possibilities, and not just volunteer ones. For instance, it took a while (who cares, I have time), but I just finished writing/publishing a book about three older friends of mine and their interesting lives. That whole creative project was engrossing, and who cares that there’s no market for a book like that? Not me. (The “who cares” feeling is a liberating one.)

    Since you asked, one door I opened and then closed three months later was getting a job as a part-time “bookseller” at a new national bookstore that was opening in my town. I thought it would be a fun way to meet like-minded people in my community while chatting about the latest great books. That expectation was wrong on so many levels. First, it was the holiday season and “part-time” went out the window since it was all-hands-on-deck time as the community showed up in droves to check out the new store. Suddenly I found myself standing for hours behind a “pay station,” and/or box-cutting open endless cartons of books and shelving (and reshelving) them, barely having time for a quick cup of water in a windowless break room, and ha! never talking about books with anyone. No time! And don’t ask about the fruitless hunt for the perfect shoes to stand in for hours behind a pay station. I needed new legs, not new shoes.

    Once the holidays were over and the customers disappeared, I learned that the “bookselling” job would turn into “doing inventory.” The easiest “bye-bye” I ever said.

    1. That’s a great insight about “who cares?”

      Also, on your bookstore experience, it reminded me of a recent freakonomics podcast with the new(ish) CEO of Waterstones and Barnes & Noble. He talks a lot about the importance of having people who know and love books in the stores and the problem with a top down approach to management (something I’m believing less and less in over time):
      https://freakonomics.com/video/amazon-was-supposed-to-kill-the-bookstore-james-daunt-had-other-plans/

      1. Laura Kelly Avatar
        Laura Kelly

        The James Daunt ethos, I now know firsthand, is more of a nice wish than a possibility in a store that is part of a national chain of thousands of similar stores. A friend of mine who works in a local indie bookstore, however, IS living the James Daunt experience (and so is Daunt in his gauzy memory of a much earlier phase of his career). Lesson learned, for me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *